
The titles sound ominous, but "Bird on a Wire", the opening track on
Rogue Wave's "Descended Like Vultures" begins with a boozy loop-waltz; a jingle-jangle, easy-trip psychedelia that lilts and wanes before the roiling, darker side of the song rears its head. Sound collages color the martial snare beats and the come-downs are punctuated with retro-space explosions. It'd be perfect music to sleep to, if the acoustic melancholia wasn't broken up by climactic squelches of fuzz, and seemingly random bursts of violent studio buggery. The song, (and the band itself), is pretty with potential like a high school wallflower that blossoms into late beauty, and it calls to mind a less user friendly Shins, or an idealized version of Neil Young that may or may not exist for all I know.
Don't make that first comparison to the guy who wrote it though. I asked Zack
Rogue, whose band was nursing a shitty case of group-wide stomach flu on the road supporting Nada Surf how often he got the Shins comparison. "Only every interview!"
Woops. It's apt in a way, but worth arguing against if only out of protesting the tired, lazy comparison shtick. "It's not for me to decide who we sound like," he said. "I think we sound like us."
That's what every band ever says, I told him. Even the most blatantly derivative. "Well, just because Bloc Party says they never listened to Gang of Four or something, that doesn't mean that we sound like the Shins. We both make melodic music...I love the Shins. I can't think of a better songwriter than James Mercer. It's just not what we do. I don't see it."
Convincing. In all fairness, one gets the impression that
Rogue Wave has seen things that would make the Shins' sweaters unravel. "Geriatric, at twenty years old...Don't do what I do...", sings
Rogue. You get the impression that these are lived-in bones, and lived-in songs. Songs that didn't graduate college, but know a lot more about what's going in the world than you do. After all, birds landing on a wire is one step between the vultures circling above and feasting on a maggoty corpse.
I asked
Rogue if he saw any vultures out the window today. "Don't you?" he said. "Look how polarized the world is becoming. Hurricanes and floods...what happens is you have companies making millions and billions of dollars off these things. It's a sign of the times. Feeding on the dead."
"Everything is political. These are spooky times. Music that lets you escape entirely is irresponsible. I don't need to lash out at particular politicians -- not directly, lyrically, but it's part of me. Of us. Being a human being that cares." That sort of political paranoia isn't overt in most of his songs,
Rogue told me. But it's in there somewhere. It's everywhere. "If you deconstruct them, even nursery rhymes are pretty creepy."
"I'm not an asshole though,"
Rogue laughed. (He's not). "Don't listen to me, I'm not a scholar." Instead, he told me, he tries to work a lot of topics into one song. There is a lot about love and disappointment, he said. And that can be intertwined with politics. Packing lyrics with multiple meanings is something he picked up from listening to Neil Young and Michael Stipe. As well as a certain musical adventurousness, or indifference from Young. "I followed Neil Young a lot when I was a kid. I liked that he was, and still is an individual. Sometimes in a caustic way, where he follows his own muse. Sometimes people didn't want to follow him where he wanted to go. I admire that."
How important is that desire to go in your own direction I asked. Is it more important to make music that sounds "new" or music that sounds "good"?
"I don't think the two have to be mutually exclusive. If you make music that is honest, it will sound new." If you try to evade everything else that has happened, he explained, it won't. "Melodies are borrowed, and people build off of them. Your personality and your experiences are what make it unique."
There is a common ground between the experimental and the traditional, and
Rogue Wave occupies that space nicely. The band was listening to a lot of My Bloody Valentine and Flaming Lips when they made the record, and it shows -- but there is a timeless tunefulness that far outweighs any of the bands reaches toward the outer limits. The songs on the record, like the breezy, breathy "California" or "Publish My Love" with the irresistible riff hook, do the heavy lifting for themselves, and influences become irrelevant. For the most part they're like portable pockets of pop-bliss you can use anywhere -- in the car, in a group with friends, or most importantly alone in your room, waiting for the birds to descend.